mybrokenshelf
Back to all kits

I'm LGBTQ+ Leaving a Conservative Faith Community

When your identity and your faith community can't coexist

If you are LGBTQ+ and leaving -- or thinking about leaving -- a conservative faith community, you are carrying a weight that most deconstruction resources do not fully address. This is not just about changing your beliefs. It is about reconciling an identity your community told you was broken with the knowledge that you are whole. The grief is real. The fear is real. And the courage it takes to be honest with yourself, even silently, is enormous. You are not alone in this, even when it feels that way.

Understanding your situation

The intersection of LGBTQ+ identity and religious deconstruction creates a particular kind of pain: the theology did not just disagree with your behavior -- it rejected who you are. Healing from that requires resources that hold both truths at once. Many people in your situation describe a double coming out -- leaving the closet and leaving the faith -- and the two processes are deeply intertwined. There is no correct order. There is no timeline. There is only your path.

Articles that help

These searches will surface articles addressing the specific intersection of LGBTQ+ identity and faith deconstruction.

Books we recommend

These books address the specific experience of being LGBTQ+ in conservative religious spaces. Each is written by someone who has lived it.

Book

Torn

by Justin Lee

A deeply personal account of growing up gay in a conservative Christian community and finding a path forward that honors both identity and faith history.

Book

God and the Gay Christian

by Matthew Vines

A careful biblical and theological argument for LGBTQ+ affirming faith -- useful for those still processing the texts that were used against them.

Book

Transforming

by Austen Hartke

A transgender Christian's exploration of scripture, identity, and belonging -- expanding the conversation beyond sexual orientation to gender identity.

Find support

You deserve support from people who understand both the religious trauma and the identity dimensions of your experience. These organizations specialize in exactly that.

Find an LGBTQ+ affirming therapist

Browse our directory of therapists who have attested to a conversion therapy prohibition.

Crisis resources

If you are in crisis, these resources are available 24/7 and understand the specific challenges facing LGBTQ+ people leaving religious communities.

The Trevor Project -- LGBTQ+ crisis support

Call 1-866-488-7386, text START to 678-678, or chat at thetrevorproject.org. Available 24/7.

Tradition-specific resources

Every tradition has its own particular history with LGBTQ+ people. Explore hub pages for resources specific to your background.